You are not logged in. Please register or login.

#1 Re: Guns N' Roses » Tracks missing from the leaked CD's » 3 weeks ago

James wrote:
AgesOfTheIce wrote:
James wrote:

Yeah .. I doubt Ides of March is Nothing. Seems like a huge stretch.

On the other hand, they seemed to have a fetish for constantly changing working titles...and if there was a brief attempt at sticking to a particular theme, it's possible Ides and Circus were two different songs.


How the hell does Oklahoma morph into Berlin? What's the connection?

Look at Seven.... God only knows what that really is. Devious Bastards has a clip of the Mercury 7 astronauts.

Coincidence?  Did they scrap this song.... obviously a Bucket song ...but reuse that clip for Seven?

There's very little rhyme or reason to any of it unfortunately.


I know one thing.....the CD leftovers and the Village leaks show us that just because a song title appears to be epic doesn't make it so...even if described as such eons ago. A song that might have been epic couldn't be because it was simply abandoned/relegated to the "B list".

Did you ever have any luck locating that 2001 setlist pic with Oklahoma as an alt for Riad? Some on Mygnr have questioned its legitimacy. Hard to have a debate either way with the pic seemingly lost media at this point.

It's lost to history.

A shit ton of GNR stuff is gone.

All that Eat My Silkworms crap

The few CD era studio pics of GNR

Shit tons of emails from Brain, Merck, etc.

No one realized back in the day the importance of archiving all that material. Remember...the internet is forever...or so they said.

By the time sic started archiving CD Whispers, a lot of this stuff was already gone.

What you're saying is completely true.
Thank god for Sic and the guys who put Chinese Whisperers together.

#2 Re: Guns N' Roses » Tracks missing from the leaked CD's » 3 weeks ago

James wrote:
Bill Brasky wrote:

Ides of March is Circus Maximus

'Ides of March' was a working title of one of the songs that came from a loop name that Dizzy came up with: I think they kept the name, but it's been years so I'm sure everything has changed by now." (Dave Dominguez, Sp1at, 02/07/05)

To quote Wasted regarding circus maximus"Would you say this has a Dizzy Loop on it?"

Yeah .. I doubt Ides of March is Nothing. Seems like a huge stretch.

On the other hand, they seemed to have a fetish for constantly changing working titles...and if there was a brief attempt at sticking to a particular theme, it's possible Ides and Circus were two different songs.


How the hell does Oklahoma morph into Berlin? What's the connection?

Look at Seven.... God only knows what that really is. Devious Bastards has a clip of the Mercury 7 astronauts.

Coincidence?  Did they scrap this song.... obviously a Bucket song ...but reuse that clip for Seven?

There's very little rhyme or reason to any of it unfortunately.


I know one thing.....the CD leftovers and the Village leaks show us that just because a song title appears to be epic doesn't make it so...even if described as such eons ago. A song that might have been epic couldn't be because it was simply abandoned/relegated to the "B list".

At one point probably between 99-04 it all made sense, There was actually a plan. Then whatever actually happened which is probably multiple things like Buckethead leaving, The 2002 tour failure, Umg cutting funding everything went out the window and madness of Roy Thomas Baker re recording everything probably feed into Axl Rose quest for perfection.

I believe Merck is responsible for more things going wrong then we will ever know.

#3 Re: Guns N' Roses » Tracks missing from the leaked CD's » 3 weeks ago

Ides of March is Circus Maximus

'Ides of March' was a working title of one of the songs that came from a loop name that Dizzy came up with: I think they kept the name, but it's been years so I'm sure everything has changed by now." (Dave Dominguez, Sp1at, 02/07/05)

To quote Wasted regarding circus maximus"Would you say this has a Dizzy Loop on it?"

#4 Re: Guns N' Roses » Tracks missing from the leaked CD's » 4 weeks ago

AtariLegend wrote:
Bill Brasky wrote:
AtariLegend wrote:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G7a0eGsb0AI … name=small

@billbrasky


Did you ever see this image yourself personally before 2019?

I answered your question already which was no i hadn't seen it before.

So for the last few days I've looked for it posted prior to the village sessions leaks and i came up with nothing.

So let me ask you this why did you ask me the question ?

@blackstar where you able to locate it prior to 2019.

@mistersaintlaurent comment ?

I asked, because its came up before and would be extremely easy to fake. 4 Heavens ect was not included in msl's original 2nd cd track list years ago (the one that included Tonto)

Maybe he can answer whether this 4heavens thing is supposed to be real, because that retrospective image is proof of nothing.

Interesting......

I guess the spelling of Nothin' speaks to it's legitimacy but there are a lot of questions.

Also there was a fan forum called 4heavens before the leaks.

Why is the cd2 tracklist nowhere to be found online before 2019 ?

Why didn't @mistersaintlaurent mention the full tracklist in his statements, it would've only given him more leverage.

I hope more people chime in so we can get a clear answer on this.

#5 Re: Guns N' Roses » Tracks missing from the leaked CD's » 4 weeks ago

AtariLegend wrote:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G7a0eGsb0AI … name=small

@billbrasky


Did you ever see this image yourself personally before 2019?

I answered your question already which was no i hadn't seen it before.

So for the last few days I've looked for it posted prior to the village sessions leaks and i came up with nothing.

So let me ask you this why did you ask me the question ?

@blackstar where you able to locate it prior to 2019.

@mistersaintlaurent comment ?

#6 Re: Guns N' Roses » Mustache » 4 weeks ago

AgesOfTheIce wrote:

Circus Maximus has never been confirmed to be connected to Ides Of March and should not be postulated as such. It's just a theory.

Until any song is officially released is it ever truly confirmed ?

#7 Re: Guns N' Roses » Mustache » 4 weeks ago

AtariLegend wrote:
polluxlm wrote:
AgesOfTheIce wrote:

Circus Maximus has never been confirmed to be connected to Ides Of March and should not be postulated as such. It's just a theory.

Unless Axl wrote multiple songs based on Ancient Rome it seems to be a good theory.

You might be right, but 2 things;

Remember how we thought Me and My Elvis was Elvis Presley and the Monster of Soul (which was renamed Monsters?) Well clearly it wasn't. Just 2 different tracks that had the words Elvis in the title. Unless it turns out Monsters isn't Soul Monster - which again would further prove the point anyway.

Also the track was supposedly called Ides of March in 98 on conception. I suppose they could have renamed it Circus Maximus in 2000 then changed the back in the early 00s to Ides again, but still... (see chinese whispers].

The definition of the word Monstrosity which appears on the cd2 tracklist is Monster.

The track Soul appears on the cd2 email track list too.

#8 Re: Guns N' Roses » Mustache » 4 weeks ago

sp1at wrote:
Shacklermyrye wrote:

@matiaslegrand
6 months ago
Song written by Pete Scaturro and Carroll. Vocals recorded by Axl in the first "remake-sessions" in 2002/2003. Discarded at the 2004 major overhaul.

That could be an educated guess any of us could have made from listening to the song

Reply

@matiaslegrand
6 days ago
@m.b4402 Yes. This song was about the french drummer and actor François-Alexandre Galepides alias Moustache, died in 1987. The chorus has samples from 'Two For The Road', a 70's film (Galepides played a role on it).

Brain and the band at the time loved sampling old movies in songs (from the 70's) they were working on & intros both in studio and live (The joint shows).. It seems like something somebody might claim if they wanted fans of that era to believe them.

Oh well, that would make sense. I noticed Brain said to me that Seven has Ben Hur in it, so it would fit in. We'll maybe never know

But that's Circus Maximus which was Ides of March.

Per Chinese Whispers
Q: [...] I am very excited about Seven. Can you tell us anything about this song? Is it a rocker?
A: ITS AN TIMELESS BALLAD WITH A BLOW YOUR FACE OFF CHORUS AND A SUCK YOUR BALL SACK BRIDGE!!!!! (Brain Mantia, Appetite for Discussion, Aug. 18, 2010)

Per your old site
Ides Of March
was a working title of one of the songs that came from a loop name that Dizzy came up with I think they kept the name but it's been years so I'm sure everything has changed by now.
https://youtu.be/Kw-jSyy863U?si=APNFj5AuuS0kP5Le

In the forum chats Axl confirmed Ides Of March and Seven separately as songs

A: Ides Of March, Oklahoma, Atlas Shrugged, Oh My God, Silkworms , Down By The Ocean (Izzy), Leave Me Alone, Seven , The General , Thyme , Quick Song , Zodiac Most all titles subject to change w/out warning and r considered working titles. (Axl Rose, chinesedemocracy.com, Dec. 2008)

Thoughts ?

#9 Re: Guns N' Roses » Monsters V20.25 » 4 weeks ago

gavgnr wrote:
Bill Brasky wrote:

Funny how it leaked the same place as The General and Monsters did.
What a coincidence !

Where did it leak?

Per Void Loykos
"It supposedly showed up first on Leaked.cx, And then some account showed up in GNR News and uploaded both of them, Children is way better sounding compared to the Instagram post Starky shared."

https://badapplesforum.com/newforum/thr … post-90482

#10 Re: Guns N' Roses » Mustache » 4 weeks ago

sp1at wrote:
UYI4 wrote:

Was sniffing through the YouTube’s and this dudes channel that has locker stuff up has mustache.  I noticed in comments some guy saying vocals recorded for this song in the “first remake sessions” in 2002/2003.  Discarded at the 2004 major overhaul?

Seems to claim it’s about some French drummer that died in 1987.

Anyone know if this is true and or how tf would someone know this
Much?  Also I’m sure there were plenty of remake sessions but a discarded overhaul of 2004 that’s news to me.

The was a French drummer called Moustache who died in 1987.

He starred in the 1970s version of Zorro, and the 70s movie is seen by some as the definitive version of Zorro

And, Zorro was regarded as bringing the bandana look into fashion for people that wore them

Whether any of it is true I don't know and the chance of Axl knowing about a French jazz drummer and occasional actor is potentially quite slim, but who knows

Interesting and i agree with you that it's a reach, But does anyone understand the thought process Axl Rose has ?

There's a track called the Curly Shuffle for instance if we are looking for similarities for absurd song title inspiration.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB