Silkworms in Vegas live is the one

misterID wrote:

Lol, I can’t think of another new era song that’s stuck with me like this one

I’m stuck on Monsters

Sky Dog wrote:

I think all the original stuff will surface at some point on a huge boxset. Why not?

Now is not the time. Once the reunion happened, CD2 was toast. It’s unfortunate because I want the dudes on there who wrote it.

I feel the same way. It’s great we get official reworking, but man the originals are just so much better. Maybe minus absurd, silkworms was better

dave-gnfnr wrote:

misterID wrote:

There’s no way this dude isn’t a troll. And if not, he’s just spamming the board with nonsense.

He is def a troll.  And he ruined two general threads

imagine calling  me of all people the biggest defender of slash when this is the first nice thing I have said about slash in over 20 years bc I think if its him on Monsters I think its his best work on the CD era stuff bc the rest was crap.

I want to know whose alt this is.

Can James just prune all his posts about Robin in both threads and dump them into a thread of its own, debating who is on these songs so it doenst ruin two threads.

He's gone now but he actually isn't a troll. Well...not a typical troll anyways. He's a true believer in everything he says. I remember this guy from the Finck forums in 2007-8. He popped back up here during the Village leaks. Had to ban him of course.

He doesn't mean any harm but Jesus Christ...it's incessant. I'd like to have just let him post but it's literally killing real discussion.