You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#111 Guns N' Roses » Rare GN'R demos on iTunes.. » 885 weeks ago
- BurningHills
- Replies: 30
http://www.mygnrforum.com/index.php?showtopic=116793
I just downloaded these myself and have no idea where these came from. They sound AMAZING. We have never heard either of these versions before on any of the bootlegs that have been floating around. It really makes you wonder what else from the old days is out there that we haven't heard yet.
#112 Re: Guns N' Roses » Mysteron confirms "Shackler's Revenge" as an actual new GN'R song » 885 weeks ago
Gunslinger wrote:Did "Shackler's Revenge" appear on this list? No.
I think there's a possibility that film score got "lost" because Axl had other ideas for what Bucket was doing on it.
Not a bad theory at all.
#113 Re: Guns N' Roses » Mysteron confirms "Shackler's Revenge" as an actual new GN'R song » 885 weeks ago
Interesting...
#114 Re: Guns N' Roses » Who's your dream replacement for Robin? » 885 weeks ago
tobias would be a disaster
Not if he was just brought in to do rhythm and the occasional lead work (like the slide solo on Rocket Queen) - I never saw the problem with him in 2001. He's not the BEST player in the world, but he has history with the band, and is probably all over the album regardless (playing wise and song writing wise.)
#115 Re: Guns N' Roses » Who's your dream replacement for Robin? » 885 weeks ago
John 5 would be a good fit if Bucket doesn't come back and Fortus isn't promoted to lead.
Ideally though, Fortus would get promoted to lead, and Paul Tobias would come back to keep some semblance of the original CD-era lineup.
#116 Re: Guns N' Roses » Song #2 (Unknown Title) » 886 weeks ago
I just extracted the "What I would do to.....myself" line, and played it over and over.
Axl is NOT singing the word "Prostitute", it's two separate words. Someone had the theory over at CD.com that it's either "Proudly damn myself.." or "Probably damn myself..." I think that I need to agree. It sounds like either one of those. Either way, the word in question is not "Prostitute."
Doesn't really mean anything or lend any credence to what the song actually is (if it isn't Prostitute), but it's worth pointing out.
#117 Re: Guns N' Roses » Song #2 (Unknown Title) » 886 weeks ago
James -
With all due respect, we now have 2 separate sources saying that Song #2 isn't Prostitute, and if I remember correctly, one of the leakers (can't remember which), said that he was still looking for Prostitute - so the leaker himself admitted that he didn't have it, unless he honestly had no idea what the song titles were/are. I'm not saying that this isn't or can't be Prostitute, but if Gunslinger heard a clip of what was supposed to be Prostitute, and it wasn't Song #2, then I think we have to say that this really is something else (My personal theory is still banking on Atlas Shrugged.)
Of course, there's still some evidence in support of it being Prostitute, as in, Rhiad & If The World were both 2006 options on the setlist along with Prostitute - 3 new songs leak, 2 of which we know were nearly played, and a mythical third track which no-one wants to fess up the title of. Not to mention, the lyrical theme seems to fit someone "prostituting" themselves for fame and fortune. If it IS Prostitute, then I'm not all that disappointed, as I do think it's a great song and one of my favorite leaks so far.
My personal, gut feeling though? It's not Prostitute. And again, I respectfully disagree with you on this one, James.
#118 Re: GN'R Downloads » Can someone link me to GNR's version of Sex, Drugs and Rock n Roll? » 886 weeks ago
GN'R never did this song.
It's an old-school Napster fake.
#119 Re: The Sunset Strip » The top 10 fan versus band scuffles » 886 weeks ago
"arse" is a funny word. 
#120 Re: Guns N' Roses » Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question? » 886 weeks ago
Fortus, Bumble, Tobias?
Could work.
