You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#191 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns n roses played the general » 97 weeks ago
Personally what I'd prefer more than anything is leaks or boxset release of CD material with the musicians who actually wrote those songs. However, it's very possible we never hear that.
Failing that I'd really like them to continue with releasing Slash/Duff reworked CD era songs, preferably as a bigger release and not a dripfeed. The dripfeed approach is really old and boring.
Failing that.... give us something completely new. I personally dont think what these guys write and produce in their 60s will be that interesting so if what that Mayhue guy said about there being Appetite and UYI era songs that were never finished I'd prefer those.
Failing that... just release more proshots in good quality like the 91 Ritz.
Really though. I just wish they'd ditch the secrecy and silence. It's not cool or mysterious. It's annoying. They aren't the pinnacle of pop culture like they were in the early 90s and they don't have the mystique of the early CD years. You have an older fan base with disposable income, talk to them and give them things to buy that they want.
The Scooby Doo sooper sekrit mystery crap should've ended the moment the album was released and/or when Ashba joined.
There was no longer anything mysterious or interesting about them at that point.
Unfortunately it somehow got wrapped up into their "brand". The UYI wait and everything surrounding it really was exciting and mysterious.
So were the early 2000s.
I think a big reason it continued into the 2010s is the fact that a supposed aura of "mystery" was the perfect disguise for incompetent management.
Management stayed the same with the reunion. Live Nation does the heavy lifting with the touring juggernaut...and what's left is handled by GNR management. Obviously what's left after the touring isn't much. 
We're damn lucky we're even getting a semi-annual release of singles. It could have so easily not even happened at all. Instead of the near constant touring that ran interest completely into the ground, they could've went away for 2-3 years and ticket sales never drop to the point they need something out there to get media interest.
It could've easily just been toy trucks and touring....
#192 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
Shacklermyrye wrote:Scabbie wrote:Yes please, I feel there should be a separate section for this type of stuff.
yeah discord or badapples
So you would rather remain with your head in the sand ?
It probably has more to do with wanting to discuss the actual songs that just leaked instead of who may or may not have songs and the drama surrounding Village Sessions discords.
It was always a niche group into that stuff (me included obviously) and that group is shrinking as we enter the final chapter.
#193 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
Big part of what makes a song great is also the context it's hears in. When you hear it, how you hear it, how it's presented and also where you are at in your life.
Get all this music out closer to when it's written and it will all hit different.
The General frankly sounds really dated, I dig it but musically it's style is well ... early 00s. It's fun to listen to but it would have been enjoyed a lot better if it came out in 02-04.
Yeah this all would've went down so much better in my mid-late 20s. While none of it is really cruising type of music, I definitely would've been cruising down McHenry with these songs blaring.
Love em or hate em...in the 2020s these songs are verging on being novelties....
The deflated myth balloon, the dated nature of the material, the horrid production/mixing issues, the vibe that it's coming to an end, and the drip feed which doesn't even allow them to be taken in as a whole.
They couldn't compile these songs into an album without am entirely new mix being done. They are too all over the place. It would be the most abrasive record ever released.
Chinese Democracy should have been something like this
Here's mine...
Chinese Democracy
Better
IRS
Sorry
Madagascar
The General
Monsters
Riad
Catcher In The Rye
Arlas Shrugged
There Was A Time
If The World
Prostitute
I would probably remove Prostitute for Street of Dreams.
Then all the left over songs could have been the b sides of the CD singles
In 2002 onstage he said the album would be 18 tracks + 10 B sides.
That's exactly what it should've been. It would've wrapped it all up nice and neat with only a small handful of unheard songs remaining.
#194 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns n roses played the general » 97 weeks ago
I'd expect maybe close to two years off unless they get a big offer for a festival. But I doubt they will as they hit many of them this year anyway.
Another option is that this is it. It's grim to think about but a lot can happen in two years. Hell they could even fall out again at some point for all we know.
We'll get the 7" and that Schenker song next year. Maybe that was a chance to just get Axl and Slash to work on something and "See how it goes". I believe they will try to do an album of new material but I doubt it will come to pass, I hope I'm wrong.
There are positive's from this year. We got a high quality level Pro shot in Glastonbury that makes the Heaven & Hell fest look like it was shot with a potato. We got Perhaps and a music video for it. A setlist that had songs nobody saw coming, leaks of The General & also Monsters and they played The General live which is not something I think anyone would have guessed at the start of the year.
It's not all bad.... However it's not all good either. Many who moaned about his voice in the CD era now yearn for it. My interest as always is in the studio material & I hope we hear more of it..
No matter how it occurs.
Yeah it is scary as a hardcore fan....
We're officially at the start of a hiatus...how long unknown and they won't tell us...which likely means another silent chapter.
If/when they come back in 2025 or 26, it will probably be a farewell tour which will coincide with two major events...40 year anniversary of the band and then AFD.
A farewell tour is unlikely to require new songs to help push it along.
Something about The General coming out has a different feel than the other releases. I have a feeling they are wrapping up the CD era and they gave us the two songs most hardcore fans wanted the most.
Like you said, anything is possible but all we're probably getting next year is the Schenker track. Since they love doing anniversaries a year late, maybe something with TSI although that's unlikely.
Unfortunately I don't really care about reunion era live stuff so anything released on that front won't float my boat.
I would love for that UYI Remix to get a release.
I guess we just pray for another drip of the Chinese feed or leaks.
#195 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
James wrote:After listening to them more the past couple says, that bass tone on Monsters really does have the Duff vibe. Was hard to tell at first. Wasn't as noticeable as Hard School.
The General is wacky. This song should not have been sat on for 20 years. It didn't warrant the hype it received but in all fairness to them, a lot of the hype for this specific song was generated by the fan base itself.
I'd like to hear it without the vocal effects... especially on that chorus.
In a way i guess we could blame Beltrami, it was he who spoke about it first on his forum in 2002/3 and then to IGN. I know we knew there was a song about child abuse but we didn't know what it was called back then. 20 fuckin years...jesus christ
Axl mentioning we'd heard it before... leading to the concert intro...gave fans a false representation of what the song was. Everyone was expecting that as an intro and/or to play throughout the song high in the mix.
So far the only big gun that is not a major disappointment. Nothing can live up to hype, but this is a great song. On average I think the unreleased tracks are better than what we got on CD. What a disaster that album was.
I'd rank Monsters above it but yeah...while neither is mind blowing...they belonged on the album. He had to realize that a follow-up was nothing more than a pipe dream and he should've just went all in on the album instead of this leaks +3 crap the album was turned into.
Remove Scraped and one of the ballads. Insert these two. If not one of those, ditch Shackler or the god awful final version of Catcher.
Have any of the so called big guns ever been that great?
Unfortunately....no.
While I do enjoy some of the material obviously, the more time goes by and more songs we hear...I can see Ezrins point of view...and the label's.
If you look at the sessions as a whole, there's a really good album buried in it. It's not Dark Side of the Moon though..not even close. In Pink Floyd terms, it's much closer to something like Meddle without Echoes or Obscured By Clouds.
Here is the thing, hearing some of these songs it makes you wonder if the reason they have not leaked is bc they are not very good and the haorders dont want to give that away so they can keep making money off of them.
Possible.
I think they could make the same amount of money on these songs regardless of quality.
Having said that...the amount willing to pay has to be shrinking.
The two big enchiladas just came out of the oven and no one is raving on them like it's my grandma's turkey dressing. It's more like my aunt's thick cut al dente french fries... kinda tasty but you need a lot of ketchup to wash it down.
#196 Re: Guns N' Roses » Justin Hawkins (The Darkness) reacting to the General » 97 weeks ago
I made it 8 minutes in.
He takes too long to get to the point... reading YouTube comments, picking up his guitar... randomness....I'm tired of these YouTube channels doing this. It's been very noticeable the past year or two. They do it because they only get money if the viewer watches a certain amount of time. A host/channel loses me when I spot the pattern.
Thanks for posting it though...I had to Google him because I forgot who in the hell Justin Hawkins is. Couldn't remember if he was a singer, guitarist, drummer....
#197 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
After listening to them more the past couple says, that bass tone on Monsters really does have the Duff vibe. Was hard to tell at first. Wasn't as noticeable as Hard School.
The General is wacky. This song should not have been sat on for 20 years. It didn't warrant the hype it received but in all fairness to them, a lot of the hype for this specific song was generated by the fan base itself.
I'd like to hear it without the vocal effects... especially on that chorus.
#198 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
Welcome Cliff.
people died without ever listening to what could have been released when they were alive.
Absolutely. I immediately thought of this when listening to both tracks that first day...how old forum friends like Tommie, Robman, EFISH, and God knows who else had waited years just praying to hear a clip of one of these big guns but died before getting the chance.
It makes me despise the hoarding crap a hell of a lot more than I used to. How many extra years do these people need to get off on having something other fans don't? Why wasn't 10-15 years enough? Some have had it longer. Is there some magic number of years where peak orgasm is reached?
Brodie/Live Free is currently in a coffin with his hoard.
Wish you'd send one to buzzsaw too. I know I'm in the minority, but I enjoyed his posts, son.
He literally begged me to ban him.... then cussed me out for banning him..came back....begged me to ban him again....I banned him.
The story ends there.
For the record...I always liked him too.
#199 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
No offense to those involved in that discussion...I love you all....but it's time to move on from that. No one is gonna budge from their position. No need for the insults either.
Is Claude still MIA? I've been gone for a couple days. Is he going to be surprised when he comes back.
Sent Bri an email. He's been gone since Hard School.
#200 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 97 weeks ago
James wrote:misterID wrote:Mojo…That dude destroyed that forum
I haven't talked to him in about 3-4 years. I don't really have anything against the guy.
Having said that...
What killed GNR Truth was the immediate censoring of the Village leaks. That forum was still rocking and rolling at that point. It went from tons of activity to a ghost town overnight. I checked it a year or two later and there were 2-3 people hanging in.
You can't prevent a starving fan base from listening to and discussing leaks. Well you can...but you see the results.
HTGTH also nosedived in activity from a similar approach.
I kinda understand where they were coming from...it was a MASSIVE leak and as we now know, GNR wound up releasing a few of those songs.
Like I said though...it's just not feasible with this fan base. Don't forget...mygnr and HTGTH initially considered such an approach in 2006-7.
Try to stop discussion...people just go to one of the other forums.
Look how many GNR forums have existed over the decades and how few were left once we got to the reunion, Village Leaks, and today.
It had a good run.
For the record, this Finck dude is definitely NOT Mojo.
A few years back Jordan Rose at Mygnr said that 95% of the other accounts on Gnrtruth were Mojo alts, and he was just talking to himself the entire time. He also said MSL abandoned the site when he found out. Have no idea if any of that was true or not.
Sounds like hyperbole.
This always happened...he gets accused of being every account on a forum.
I'll say this before moving on....
He deserved to move on from that WC stuff. It was ancient history. Some people liked stirring up drama too much to let it go.
Didn’t MSL sell the site to a female member there? It was her and mojo, and they wouldn’t let anyone say anything negative about the band.
Yes.
I also don't remember her name.
People knew going in that it was a 100% positive pro GNR forum. That wasn't the problem..it still had plenty of activity. It was the censoring of the leaks that did it.
I’m convinced he was UziSuicidal
It was multiple people juggling that account.
