You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#601 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
dave-gnfnr wrote:war wrote:dave, steve doesnt have the range that axl does.
also, axl was spot on for patience until the end when it became falsetto time
hes lost his upper range - its that simple
Steven Tyler can sing higher than axl but axl can go lower.
Axls mid range sucks now, while tylers when he was 50 was still very goodi dont agree.
tylers natural range is higher
axls natural range is lowerthey are different types of voices
axl used to reach the notes tyler still does and had a larger range
but tyler never could reach the lower notes
age, care, etc are all given as reasons for that but dont make a difference for....
the fact remains axl has lost that upper range
you can say tyler is better in the long run and ur half right
lower degree of difficulty and ability but tyler is better off because he can still sing his own material properly
vocal range has NOTHING to do with singing or how good you sound. Axl cant even sing low anymore as well, his lower register is awful.
Axl doesnt even need his upper register for most of the stuff he played tonight and he was still terrible.
#602 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
I agree with that War....I just think the status quo makes it worse.
Like i say...when Vince has a shit night in motley...you can focus on Nikki or Tommy or whatever. People can't do that with GNR.
yes they can because DJ sucks A LOT but axl is just that bad they go for him. Plus the average fan doesnt expect much since his backing band is a bunch of nobodies (save tommy).
#603 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
dave, steve doesnt have the range that axl does.
also, axl was spot on for patience until the end when it became falsetto time
hes lost his upper range - its that simple
Steven Tyler can sing higher than axl but axl can go lower.
Axls mid range sucks now, while tylers when he was 50 was still very good
#604 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
dave-gnfnr wrote:RussTCB wrote:Here's what I don't get. Where are these posters when anything is going right? In the weeks leading up to this show, did we have the services of these posters? Nope. They were apparently waiting in the wings for something they didn't like so they could post about it.
As far as I'm concerned, you can open up a 3rd account at mygnr for that sort of thing. Because the people that post here regularly give an actual shit about what's happening with the band or at the very least there fellow board members. They don't sit in the wings waiting to pounce on every negative thing that happens in the world of GN'R.
You actually have it backwards. US fans come back after each disaster (like RIO to now) to give Axl another chance, and then of course he lets those fans down AGAIN and AGAIN.
The problem is Axl fails 99% of the time so of course most things are going to be negative.
Maybe we thought since axl had these shows, had jimmy lined up plus those vegas shows maybe he got his shit together. And what happened? He didnt, he just didnt even try to get in shape for this show.
Wouldnt you think with all the time he had off, he could have gotten in shape physically and also gotten his voice in shape?
The end story is this: if you don't like it, don't look/listen.
But again, that's your game; to be negative.
I am just honest, and I am far from negative, Axl did nothing tonight to warrant praise. What did I say that was not true?
#605 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
dave-gnfnr wrote:Steven Tyler was 50 is 2000 right?
He looked great and sounded good example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfXRGd4pYEkAge has nothing to do with it
Yes. And Axl could sing that song just fine currently. Please have any idea what you're talking about when it comes to vocal ranges and performances before posting examples again.
No he couldnt, axl couldnt even sing patience and that song is easy. Axl sounded like shit.
Axl had it easy tonight and failed big time. Steven tyler is a much better vocalist than axl and he actually gives a shit
Hell axl cant even keep this breath for a whole song, he barely got through better.
#606 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
Here's what I don't get. Where are these posters when anything is going right? In the weeks leading up to this show, did we have the services of these posters? Nope. They were apparently waiting in the wings for something they didn't like so they could post about it.
As far as I'm concerned, you can open up a 3rd account at mygnr for that sort of thing. Because the people that post here regularly give an actual shit about what's happening with the band or at the very least there fellow board members. They don't sit in the wings waiting to pounce on every negative thing that happens in the world of GN'R.
You actually have it backwards. US fans come back after each disaster (like RIO to now) to give Axl another chance, and then of course he lets those fans down AGAIN and AGAIN.
The problem is Axl fails 99% of the time so of course most things are going to be negative.
Maybe we thought since axl had these shows, had jimmy lined up plus those vegas shows maybe he got his shit together. And what happened? He didnt, he just didnt even try to get in shape for this show.
Wouldnt you think with all the time he had off, he could have gotten in shape physically and also gotten his voice in shape?
#607 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
Steven Tyler was 50 is 2000 right?
He looked great and sounded good example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfXRGd4pYEk
Age has nothing to do with it
#608 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
What cake? Axl ate the whole thing as you can see by his double chin
#609 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
Bro-mero wrote:Axl forgot the words in Welcome To The Jungle at one point
Yes he made a mistake. How human of him?
war wrote:better was cool
russ - axl souned good and only sounded good when he sang in his natural range..
yet he chose to sing falsetto in parts of used to love her when the studio version would have been natural range.
it makes no sense - does he not know how bad his highss sound these days?
why not cater the songs to his natural range.
heres an idea....releaes a new album without the 6 octave range
new material that everyone wants and that you can sing live
at this rate hes killing his career
I get what you're saying, but I think he did ok. You have to remember that he's in a state of damned if he does, damned it he's doesn't. Dude couldn't come out tonight and killed it, yet all of our armchair performers would've second guess him every step of the way.
He didnt kill it now did he? He didnt even try, that is the problem.
And its fans like you who put up with it and give him a pass that makes him keep doing it.
Rio was a disaster and this is rio all over again.
Now I am pretty sure they are playing again tomorrow.
lets see how he rebounds, if its more of hte same then what?
#610 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N' Roses, Jack White set for Bridge School Benefit » 662 weeks ago
Russ Axl is not even trying anymore. You can tell he has not practiced in a long long time and how the hell can he forgot the words to jungle
