Please describe "completed" or "earlier origins".

There's piano and acoustic versions of November Rain from the era before Appetite was recorded. If you say it's only completed after the horns and strings arrangements, perhaps that's the same with all CD era songs and vault, since they're all full of it? We'll never know, to be honest. It was mentioned on interviews that You Could Be Mine was kept for future releases and was ready to AFD.

"Completed" is a term that means different things for you, for me and, surprisingly, even for Axl.

If you want just to bash, it's ok, but don't try to act like you're not being almost irrational on your arguments just to try to prove a point.

And, still, you didn't reply my question.

It was not an interview per se, it was a brief talk for the endorser, ESP, who now has a Tommy Stinson bass!

It was MARKETING, not an interview.

Most of lyrics in ChinDem sound like reactions to betrayal and mistrust.

Even This I Love ("now I don't know why she wouldn't say goodbye"), Scraped ("you're more than they tell you"), etc.

It may not be true in fact, but that seems to be his feeling for the last 15+ years: he was betrayed.

Yeah, I think Russ is spot on right about it. It comes from frustration, like "whatever..."

Monkey, I have the same feeling and interpretation of the songs on CD, and I think it's really genuine and truthful.

Thanks guys!