You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#871 Re: Guns N' Roses » There was a time live » 888 weeks ago
not as bad as i was expecting
BBF didn't do too badly - parts of it sound reasonably similar
theres no doubt BH has a cleaner, more distinct and emotional sound though
#872 Re: Guns N' Roses » How many times have you seen GN'R live? » 888 weeks ago
Once.
July 1991.
Had tickets to see them in 06 but it was canceled so they could finish and release the album. Was also gonna go in 02 but the tour was canceled before it reached my area.
unbelieveable
#873 Guns N' Roses » New Telegraph article » 888 weeks ago
- jimmythegent
- Replies: 1
Don't think his has been posted - not a bad read
#874 Re: Guns N' Roses » How many times have you seen GN'R live? » 888 weeks ago
just the once - Auckland, NZ last year
was fun - rehash tour and all, would love to see a reunion - that would be more than fun, that would be akin to a religious experience
#875 Re: Guns N' Roses » IGN: Axl Needs To Go Solo » 888 weeks ago
Well I guess you could say this is pretty much stating the obvious, but my question would be, if Axl were going to do this, why would he suddenly do an about-face right now?
Just speculating, but i'm thinking one of the key reasons this thing has been delayed again and again in recent years, is because management and the record company are trying to formulate the perfect way to release this so as to give Axl an 'out' if you were. A way in which Axl can save face, have a guaranteed 'success' while still leaving the door open to a reunion, keeping the legacy in tact and most importantly, not diminishing or weakening the legacy and thus back catalogue sales. The Best Buy thing seems to add creedance to this theory.
Releasing CD as a solo venture or something similar would seem logical from this perspective, as would James' theory of marketing it in a NIN-type way - where Axl is GN'R and there is no touring or videos etc... to point out to Joe Public that Slash and co. are not around
But again, why would Axl suddenly do an about face after this long?
#876 Re: Guns N' Roses » Rankings/comments on all the new songs » 889 weeks ago
I'll repost my segment of another post in this thread.
For the life of me, I cant understand why anyone would rank Prostitute so lowly - just goes to show different strokes for different folks I guess...
i'll rate the 10 tracks likely to be on CD from best to worst (IMO) that we've heard.
1. Song #2, Prostitute - this song is epic and a completed version has me salivating in anticipation. This is the only song so far, that comes close to the dizzying epics of the UYI era.
2. Better - quite simply the best rocker we've heard from this new band/project. Strip away a little of the dated sounding techno flourishes and you have an assured hit - my wife even likes this one.
3. The Blues - Still holding out hope that this will emerge fully realised and as huge and grand as it ought to be. Bring back the original intro please.
4. Chinese Democracy - Good solid opener, and those newer rhythym tracks do the trick nicely
5. There was a time - A good song- potentially great, but not the soaring brilliance some GN'R fans are proposing it is. The solo is very good indeed, but it doesn't resonate as emotionally as Slash's playing for me. Sorry to compare, but I can't help but think what he could have done with a track like this (and others)
6. Rhiad and the bedouins - was afraid it was 'filler-ish', but it's grown on me and a beefier mix (the rhythym section and guitars could be grunted up I reckon) should do the trick.
7. Shacklers revenge - not a bad song, but overall, pretty forgettable. I'm happy with it - I think it's one of those songs that out of context in terms of the rest of the album, seems a bit confused. BBF plays great here.
8. If the world - thought it was a turd at first, but it's ok now. A bit unfocused sounding to me. Certainly offers (further) diversity.
9. IRS - A weak rocker I feel - I'd be happy if it were left off. Reeks of B-side material.
10. Madagascar - anyone that i've chatted with/debated over the years knows my thoughts on this one. I still feel it's a turkey. Plodding, dated, over-earnest sub-UYI pap.
**** Catcher in the Rye is an absolute gem and should be on CD in a heartbeat. I would rate it top 3 in this list if I thought it were going to be on the album
#877 Re: Guns N' Roses » Number of tracks etc... » 889 weeks ago
so no update on the site huh....
#878 Guns N' Roses » Number of tracks etc... » 889 weeks ago
- jimmythegent
- Replies: 17
Sorry if this has been discussed in another thread, but has there been any speculatation as to how many tracks CD will include? Did I read somewhere that it is likely to be 15 or do we still go on what Axl said in early 2006 as to there being 13?
For obvious reasons, I really hope 15. We've likely heard at least 10 that will be included, so I could be pretty excited by 5 brand spanking new ones. Hopefully "big guns" at that. But only 3, well I'll still be beside myself (proper mastered/mixed and completed), but a little less so.
But in saying that, I'm looking forward to several aspects:
- the cover art and sleeve
- liner notes
- credits
- being able to listen to the album in sequence as was intended or as a whole. This is a biggie - as I guess you'd say this falls into the category of 'concept' album, it's quite possible that listening to individual tracks in isolation detract from the potency of the whole.
- post- release interviews with Axl (if they occur)
- reviews and general reception by the public
- sharing views with the community
It's going to be a momentus occasion for sure and I'm finally allowing myself to get excited again!
For the hell of it, i'll rate the 10 tracks likely to be on CD from best to worst (IMO) that we've heard.
1. Song #2, Prostitute - this song is epic and a completed version has me salivating in anticipation. This is the only song so far, that comes close to the dizzying epics of the UYI era.
2. Better - quite simply the best rocker we've heard from this new band/project. Strip away a little of the dated sounding techno flourishes and you have an assured hit - my wife even likes this one.
3. The Blues - Still holding out hope that this will emerge fully realised and as huge and grand as it ought to be. Bring back the original intro please.
4. Chinese Democracy - Good solid opener, and those newer rhythym tracks do the trick nicely
5. There was a time - A good song- potentially great, but not the soaring brilliance some GN'R fans are proposing it is. The solo is very good indeed, but it doesn't resonate as emotionally as Slash's playing for me. Sorry to compare, but I can't help but think what he could have done with a track like this (and others)
6. Rhiad and the bedouins - was afraid it was 'filler-ish', but it's grown on me and a beefier mix (the rhythym section and guitars could be grunted up I reckon) should do the trick.
7. Shacklers revenge - not a bad song, but overall, pretty forgettable. I'm happy with it - I think it's one of those songs that out of context in terms of the rest of the album, seems a bit confused. BBF plays great here.
8. If the world - thought it was a turd at first, but it's ok now. A bit unfocused sounding to me. Certainly offers (further) diversity.
9. IRS - A weak rocker I feel - I'd be happy if it were left off. Reeks of B-side material.
10. Madagascar - anyone that i've chatted with/debated over the years knows my thoughts on this one. I still feel it's a turkey. Plodding, dated, over-earnest sub-UYI pap.
Anyway, Novemeber 25th can't come quick enough for me I can tell you.
#879 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N Roses on Universal Music Group Release List » 890 weeks ago
Metallica are on Warners now
#880 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N Roses on Universal Music Group Release List » 890 weeks ago
wow
finally looks like CD could in fact be a reality
heres hoping