You are not logged in. Please register or login.

#81 Re: Guns N' Roses » Skwerl's post on MyGNR regarding his leak and his source » 677 weeks ago

Ali
otto wrote:
faldor wrote:
gavgnr wrote:

Hey otto, very cool of you to post that stuff about what you heard. Any idea of the names of the tracks you partially heard?

I wonder if these tracks will ever leak? My gut tells me no. By the sounds of the other stuff otto heard these tracks have been in the hands of various people for quite some time now. No reason to think they're suddenly goin to leak now....unfortunately

First off, I see no reason why Otto would lie, so I choose to believe him.  I mean, what does he have to gain really?  He isn't claiming to HAVE the songs.  I guess you could argue he knows someone who does, so he could use that to his advantage if he wanted to get involved with any hoarders that are still laying in the weeds.  But, he's been pretty consistent over the years, as opposed to the other fake insiders.  So I trust him.

One thing I've wondered though.  What's the big deal about not wanting to share lyrics from the unheard songs?  I wondered that when Halo was going on and on about it on HTGTH, dangling it out there like he had some major prize.  Maybe I'm in the minority, but lyrics to a song I've never heard or can't even imagine what it sounds like, doesn't do a whole lot for me.  So why is it a no no to post these lyrics?

Hi Faldor, thanks for the vote of confidence.

I think the lyrics could identify the song, therefore could identify the source(s) in case of potential leaks. I'm pretty sure my "source" doesn't want to get identified or related to or by whomever could take action in case something leaks. I need to clarify though that the people I know are/were not directly connected to GN'R in any form.

I have no intention of pursuing hoarders in order to trade anything, first of all because I got nothing to offer. On the other hand, I would love to hear some new tracks because I get the feeling we won't be hearing a official release anytime soon.

I tried to join a closed group of Youtube taken down rare videos on facebook, to see if perhaps there's somebody onhold of something.. Perhaps it's even somebody who doesn't know how rare a GNR leak would be...

Otto,

I just wanted to say thanks for sharing the information.  As opposed to Halo69/AndreCC/AxlRoseCaliformia/whatever else, the way in which you disclosed this information says a lot.

Ali

#82 Re: Guns N' Roses » Skwerl's post on MyGNR regarding his leak and his source » 677 weeks ago

Ali
-D- wrote:

Saying myles can't sing is ridiculous.

Who said that?

I think he has great range and talent in his voice.  I just don't like his tone much of the time, especially in the upper portion of his range.

Ali

#83 Re: Guns N' Roses » Axl at the Golden Globes afterparty » 677 weeks ago

Ali
-D- wrote:

Listen to everything else

In case it wasn't clear, I was at all the shows (12/21/2011 in LA, and the 11/23 and 11/24/2012 Vegas shows) for the entirety of the shows, not just "This I Love".

Ali

#84 Re: Guns N' Roses » Skwerl's post on MyGNR regarding his leak and his source » 677 weeks ago

Ali
metallex78 wrote:
Ali wrote:
metallex78 wrote:

Only difference between Myles and Axl these days, is that Axl sings pitchy out of key, and Myles sings pitchy IN key.

Axl has no rasp like he once did, and Myles never sang with rasp, but always sings in key.

All of those statements, stated the way they are as unequivocal truths, are flawed to say the least.

Ali

Don't be a hater just because you know what I say is true. 22

No hating.  It's just these aren't unequivocal truths 22

Ali

#85 Re: Guns N' Roses » Axl at the Golden Globes afterparty » 677 weeks ago

Ali
DCK wrote:

Rock singing isn't opera, and his voice is weaker now than it has been for a very very long time. Not talking about the rasp, talking about the rest of it.

That's debatable to say the least.  My girlfriend and I attended the LA Forum show on 12/21/2011 and the last two shows of the Vegas residency and neither of us could hear any difference in performance.

As far as a "weak" voice goes, a "weak" voice would not be able to sustain the last note in the last chorus of "This I Love" as long as he did when I saw him and with as strong a vibrato as he did.  I'm sorry, but that is not the hallmark of a "weak" voice IMO.

Ali

#86 Re: Guns N' Roses » Skwerl's post on MyGNR regarding his leak and his source » 677 weeks ago

Ali
metallex78 wrote:

Only difference between Myles and Axl these days, is that Axl sings pitchy out of key, and Myles sings pitchy IN key.

Axl has no rasp like he once did, and Myles never sang with rasp, but always sings in key.

All of those statements, stated the way they are as unequivocal truths, are flawed to say the least.

Ali

#87 Re: Guns N' Roses » Axl at the Golden Globes afterparty » 677 weeks ago

Ali
DCK wrote:

The look he's got is fine, it's his bloated face that fucks him up. He's closing in on Vince Neil as the most silly bloated rock vocalist ever. Fine, he's 50 years old. There's genes involved and a life style.

Doesn't look like he's even trying to keep some sort of weight limit.

But the most ironic thing is, truly fucking ironic is that the press gave him shit 10 years ago for being fat. Even in 2006 they gave him shit for being fat. It was absolutely redicilous of anyone to call the guy fat. The dude was in better shape than I ever was.

Now it looks like he was stuck McDonalds drinking beers and eating hamburgers for five years straight.

And I fear his stamina and voice will suffer directly and indirectly from this.

Interesting though, I would welcome a fat fight between Vince and Axl now. For the first time it would be funny.

Refuse him any tours until he looses at least 10 kgs.

I've heard the argument that caring about a singer's weight is because of concerns that it affects their performance many times.  I don't buy it.  If you practice proper diaphragmatic breathing, you can take in enough air to support your voice.  There are many heavier-set singers that have done this over time. 

Of course, if you move around while you sing, you will expel more air than you would otherwise.  If you sing in the upper portion of your range, you will expel more air and consequently need more air to support your voice.

Singing is not athletics, though. There isn't that same direct link between weight/body fat/fitness and performance as there would in basketball (as an example).

Ali

#88 Re: Guns N' Roses » The Definitive Chinese Democracy Leaks Thread » 678 weeks ago

Ali
faldor wrote:
Intercourse wrote:
faldor wrote:

I didn't think Jarmo went below the belt with any of the things he said. Halo did. He got personal and a bit nasty. And even if he felt ganged up on, just because you may feel insulted, the answer isn't always to fire it up a notch and go for the jugular. It's clear to me that Halo is trying to make a name for himself so he can brag to his internet friends on various other GNR websites. "Hey, have you guys been following me schooling Jarmo on HTGTH? How awesome am I?"

Plus, the guy seems to be full of shit. He claims to know things he has no clue about and he changes his story. Not too long ago he claimed that an album would be out in 2013, now he's backed off of that. He's an attention seeker, plain and simple.

That, in my mind makes him a giant douche.

Jesus Faldo, Jarmo told him to "Fuck Off" told him was nothing, a nobody etc...where did Halo get worse than that??? Even the saner posters called Jarmo out for his insults to Halo and other posters. You would NEVER see the mods here behave the same way..

I am not here to defend Halo, I have not been to HGTH in a year or more and don't know him at all, never heard of him, but I did not see the guy be in any way more posionous as anybody else there. What he said was true in many cases.

I think you're dragging in other situations into this to form an overall opinion of Halo but for an outsider like me looking in on the Jarmo show, I think that boy has lost it. He's either an arrogant tosser who feels king of his tiny hill or a scared little soldier who is terrified of his boss.

Its probably a bit of both I reckon.

Yeah, I've heard Halo spew his shit for the better part of the last year, so my opinion on him isn't solely based off this one back and forth with Jarmo.  He's a wannabe insider who claims to know things and have things he doesn't seem to have.  An attention seeker.  So in my mind, I don't blame Jarmo for going off on him.

I'm one of the few who don't have a problem with Jarmo.  He's employed by the band, it's his board, he can run it however he sees fit.  There are plenty of other places to discuss GNR.  I post here more often than HTGTH these days because there's so little activity over there, or at least any interesting activity.  So I don't see why people bother hating on Jarmo.  What's the point?  You don't like the way he does things, post somewhere else.  What does bitching about him accomplish?

By the way, Halo now says the next album will come out in 2014, moving further from his 2013 prediction.  Maybe he'll acquire a few more unheard tracks in the meantime and he can brag about how they sound and not share them with anyone.  Can't wait!

I'm with faldor on this. 

If Jarmo called him a nothing or nobody - which I admit I may have missed among the many posts back and forth - that would certain change my view of the interaction.  But, as it stands, I didn't see, or I don't recall, anything like that.  So, I don't see anything wrong with what Jarmo said in the thread.  Halo/Andre was taunting him, which I thought was kind of childish, but other than that his opinions are his opinions.  But, I think playing the "insider" card was the asinine thing I saw in that thread.  I don't believe Halo/Andre has any songs, and even if he did, what he did by posting mere descriptions of songs seemed like nothing more than an attention-seeking ploy, be it for attention in and of itself or in an attempt to try and lure out a hoarder looking to make a trade.

As far as Jarmo goes, I agree with faldor again.  As a general rule of thumb, if you don't like his site, don't post there.  The minute you stop posting there is the minute it stops having any effect on your GN'R messageboard-going at all.  It is his site and a free one at that.  There's no loss in ceasing to post there. 

And, I can't help but think of the fact that the people that complain about him the most, from my observations and recollections, are not the people who've actually met the guy.  There have been several posters who've met him over the years and said he was polite and courteous, including the guys from the Talking Metal podcast who interviewed him several years ago.   Which isn't to dismiss any complaints about the way he runs his site, if you have any.  Just an observation that like the GN'R shows themselves, there seems to be a difference in opinion when observing from afar vs. based on first-hand experience. 14

Ali

#89 Re: Guns N' Roses » Tokyo 2012 Ear Monitor Clips » 679 weeks ago

Ali
Me_Wise_Magic wrote:

Very good performance from what I heard. Used to Love Her was great from another video I watched from that same show.

Agreed.

But, I never saw a UTLH clip from this show?  Do you have a YouTube link you can post?

Thanks,

Ali

#90 Re: Guns N' Roses » Dizzy Reed Interview Jakarta Post » 681 weeks ago

Ali
faldor wrote:
buzzsaw wrote:

I guess what he doesn't see is that he's had the opportunity for years (and still has) to change the perception of him, but all he does is further cement the existing opinion of him.  People would listen if he'd just talk.  People would care if he would release quality new music.  People would care if he would make an attempt to be more fan friendly.  But that's just not who he is.

Right.  Easier said than done.  Some people have the ability to change people's perceptions of them.  Axl seems to lack that.  Again, deep down I don't think he minds that people hate him so much, but he doesn't understand why he can't continue to prosper as an artist.  I think the two go hand in hand more than he'd like to acknowledge.

Does he really lack the ability to change people's perception of him, or does he just not care enough to make the effort on a consistent basis?  He showed he can be polite and even funny on Jimmy Kimmel.  For some people, that may have changed their perception of his likeability.  He just doesn't do things like that on a consistent basis, for better or for worse.

I don't know what you mean by "prosper as an artist".  If you mean commercial success, then sure, I can see how being more well-liked would help your commercial success.  If you mean prosper creatively and artistically, I'm not sure you need to be liked in order to create art that speaks to people.

Ali

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB