Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Bill Brasky

mister saint laurent wrote:

I suggest this dispute be settled with a tennis match.

Tennis is for women.

Bill Brasky

AtariLegend wrote:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G7a0eGsb0AI … name=small
@billbrasky

Did you ever see this image yourself personally before 2019?

I answered your question already which was no i hadn't seen it before.

So for the last few days I've looked for it posted prior to the village sessions leaks and i came up with nothing.

So let me ask you this why did you ask me the question ?

@blackstar where you able to locate it prior to 2019.

@mistersaintlaurent comment ?

AtariLegend

Bill Brasky wrote:

AtariLegend wrote:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G7a0eGsb0AI … name=small
@billbrasky

Did you ever see this image yourself personally before 2019?
I answered your question already which was no i hadn't seen it before.
So for the last few days I've looked for it posted prior to the village sessions leaks and i came up with nothing.
So let me ask you this why did you ask me the question ?
@blackstar where you able to locate it prior to 2019.
@mistersaintlaurent comment ?

I asked, because its came up before and would be extremely easy to fake. 4 Heavens ect was not included in msl's original 2nd cd track list years ago (the one that included Tonto)

Maybe he can answer whether this 4heavens thing is supposed to be real, because that retrospective image is proof of nothing.

Bill Brasky

AtariLegend wrote:

Bill Brasky wrote:
AtariLegend wrote:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G7a0eGsb0AI … name=small
@billbrasky

Did you ever see this image yourself personally before 2019?
I answered your question already which was no i hadn't seen it before.
So for the last few days I've looked for it posted prior to the village sessions leaks and i came up with nothing.
So let me ask you this why did you ask me the question ?
@blackstar where you able to locate it prior to 2019.
@mistersaintlaurent comment ?
I asked, because its came up before and would be extremely easy to fake. 4 Heavens ect was not included in msl's original 2nd cd track list years ago (the one that included Tonto)
Maybe he can answer whether this 4heavens thing is supposed to be real, because that retrospective image is proof of nothing.

Interesting......

I guess the spelling of Nothin' speaks to it's legitimacy but there are a lot of questions.

Also there was a fan forum called 4heavens before the leaks.

Why is the cd2 tracklist nowhere to be found online before 2019 ?

Why didn't @mistersaintlaurent mention the full tracklist in his statements, it would've only given him more leverage.

I hope more people chime in so we can get a clear answer on this.

carlossacanell

So we already have
Absurd
Hard skhool
Perhaps
TG
Atlas
Nothing

And we know about
Monsters
State of grace
Seven
Thyme
A new versión of Oh My God?
Eye on you
Me & my Elvis?
Quick song?
Zodiac

Anything else?

Shacklermyrye

carlossacanell wrote:

So we already have
Absurd
Hard skhool
Perhaps
TG
Atlas
Nothing
And we know about
Monsters
State of grace
Seven
Thyme
A new versión of Oh My God?
Eye on you
Me & my Elvis?
Quick song?
Zodiac
Anything else?

Oklahoma/ Berlin
Ides Of March 1998 according to Dominguez. He said these were the ones they bought in most complete I think and that would have been January 98, therefore they could be from 1997. Axl got the Idea for Oklahoma In 1995 just after the bombing (same week Izzy and Duff were doing Machine Gun ect) So I guess it depends on what you consider the start of a song writing process, either 95 or 98 take your pick

As It Began parts of which were played live in 2002

Dragon If you except the Engle & Engle paperwork is real
The Rebel (from memory the CD was burned same month RTB was being interviewed at The Village along with Caram)

Oh My God Remix (not bbf version)

Depends on if you count the remixes I guess but this specific one has been largely forgotten by people. I think that years after those forum chats when the BBF guitar stem version leaked people assumed that was what Axl was speaking about back in 2008. However that version does not have new vocals and whilst the new guitar solo by BBF can certainly be described as wild, it’s clear that it’s not on the intro.

“There's a remix w/lots of new vocals and a wilder guitar intro but it's not taken all that seriously. ( AXL Chinesedemocracy.com December 14, 2008).

This basically confirms that not all of the Brain remixes are out there. Remember those half time shows where Brain and Mellissa played that version of Sorry along with the Better remix's? It's likely that there may be a version Of Sorry too.

carlossacanell

Shacklermyrye wrote:

carlossacanell wrote:
So we already have
Absurd
Hard skhool
Perhaps
TG
Atlas
Nothing
And we know about
Monsters
State of grace
Seven
Thyme
A new versión of Oh My God?
Eye on you
Me & my Elvis?
Quick song?
Zodiac
Anything else?
Oklahoma/ Berlin
Ides Of March 1998 according to Dominguez. He said these were the ones they bought in most complete I think and that would have been January 98, therefore they could be from 1997. Axl got the Idea for Oklahoma In 1995 just after the bombing (same week Izzy and Duff were doing Machine Gun ect) So I guess it depends on what you consider the start of a song writing process, either 95 or 98 take your pick

As It Began parts of which were played live in 2002
Dragon If you except the Engle & Engle paperwork is real
The Rebel (from memory the CD was burned same month RTB was being interviewed at The Village along with Caram)
Oh My God Remix (not bbf version)
Depends on if you count the remixes I guess but this specific one has been largely forgotten by people. I think that years after those forum chats when the BBF guitar stem version leaked people assumed that was what Axl was speaking about back in 2008. However that version does not have new vocals and whilst the new guitar solo by BBF can certainly be described as wild, it’s clear that it’s not on the intro.
“There's a remix w/lots of new vocals and a wilder guitar intro but it's not taken all that seriously. ( AXL Chinesedemocracy.com December 14, 2008).
This basically confirms that not all of the Brain remixes are out there. Remember those half time shows where Brain and Mellissa played that version of Sorry along with the Better remix's? It's likely that there may be a version Of Sorry too.

Yes. I ask cause i assume we are going to get this singles format of allí/some of them during the band keeps together before new Slash/Duff/Axl songs/album get released. So if i'm right, i' d like to know how many CD era songs left for Axl. Only Axl knows

Blackstar

Shacklermyrye wrote:

Ides Of March 1998 according to Dominguez. He said these were the ones they bought in most complete I think and that would have been January 98, therefore they could be from 1997. Axl got the Idea for Oklahoma In 1995 just after the bombing (same week Izzy and Duff were doing Machine Gun ect) So I guess it depends on what you consider the start of a song writing process, either 95 or 98 take your pick

I'm curious to see if Dizzy gets a writing credit for Nothin'. If so, I think it's possible that Nothin' is Ides of March (Dominguez said it was a Dizzy loop).

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Re: Tracks missing from the leaked CD's

Board footer