You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
ok, but why no word from Robin himself? he has always been a communicative person..
Really? Buckethead talks more than Finck.
Maybe at some point in the next decade Finck will write a poem about it.
when BH leaved the band, Axl made a statement.
That's because it was a huge blow to the project at that point. Someone leaving now doesn't really mean much.
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
Yeah, Trent just nailed the coffin shut on the Finck era of GNR. Any wishes for Finck from here on out is just pipe dream fantasy land stuff.
Well it looks bleak, but I would have said the same about 
and there is at least a few hints and cryptic messages that may be back in some capacity.
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
I believe Axl pulled the plug on that RIR show, Buckethead then quit because he had had enough of the timewasting and shitting on fans, and Axl Spinmaster Rose put out his press release to save his own face.
Bucket was out playing gigs immediately afterwards, Rose never surfaced for another 2 years, 4 years after the 2002 debacle, and the album still never surfaced for 4 years after Bucket leaving. Buckethead was still the main man on that album and the same vocals were on it.
- A Private Eye
- Rep: 77
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
I believe Axl pulled the plug on that RIR show, Buckethead then quit because he had had enough of the timewasting and shitting on fans, and Axl Spinmaster Rose put out his press release to save his own face.
Bucket was out playing gigs immediately afterwards, Rose never surfaced for another 2 years, 4 years after the 2002 debacle and the album still never surfaced for 4 years after that. Buckethead was still the main man on that album and the same vocals were on it.
Nah, RIR got cancelled because Axl couldn't find an adequate replacement for BH. If the reports are right I think BH had unofficially gone before GNR were even booked for RIR, so he'd left way before the cancellation.
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
I'm pretty sure GNR were announced to be there before it was announced Bucket quit.
http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/148605 … lines=true
Says there Bucket was excited about Rock In Rio.
*edit:
http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/148581 … oses.jhtml
Rio was booked before Bucket left*
Whether or not Axl pulled the plug on Rio, I think he pulled the plug on any pretence to the band that the album was coming and Bucket then jumped ship.
I dont think Brains heart was in touring with no album either in 2006. Didnt he say "I'll come back when the album is released" or something to that effect.
Sometimes I wonder if the people who have walked away are the people who have the most integrity towards the Guns N Roses fanbase.
Didnt Tommy Stinson's friend comment that Stinson had happily made 2 million dollars, from just sitting on his backside for a couple of years.
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
I dont think Brains heart was in touring with no album either in 2006. Didnt he say "I'll come back when the album is released" or something to that effect.
no that was speculation from us negative folk....most people insisted he was on an extended parental leave 
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
I wonder at what point in the tour Axl pulled the plug on releasing the album.
I wouldnt be suprised if Brain was planning on coming back after the birth of his baby, but when on leave he found out the album was on hold yet again.
I cant remember what the speculation on the boards were, it was a very exciting time. A great tour lined up with Axl telling us the album was coming out that year. Brain leaving was not a huge event.
Bizarrely enough, the excitement GNR fans experienced in 2006 blows this wet fart of an album release out the water.
Re: NIN imploding? Finck coming back? (NOPE!)
I cant remember what the speculation on the boards were, it was a very exciting time. A great tour lined up with Axl telling us the album was coming out that year. Brain leaving was not a huge event.
depends what board you were posting on...it was a big deal around here 
alot of us were sorry to see him go...in fact the finck departure and the brain departure were pretty close in importance to members of this board
