Board footer

AtariLegend

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

AtariLegend wrote:

The subject matter is self-explanatory...

-edit-

btw...

This poll was a joke, the subject of Paul's history in the band, isn't.

BLS-Pride

 Rep: 212 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

BLS-Pride wrote:

Slash. No real need to explain either.

Communist China

 Rep: 130 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

Communist China wrote:

Slash. Saying Tobias is silly.

-D-

 Rep: 231 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

-D- wrote:

Is this a serious thread?

Sky Dog

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

Sky Dog wrote:

The subject matter is self-explanatory...

Which guitarist had the greater influence... creatively in the music, not the commercial success.

Paul Huge

-Half of the "Appetite For Destruction" Demos
-Some of "Lies" Demos
-Several of the "Use Your Illusion" Demos
-Most of "Chinese Democracy"

Slash

-Half of the "Appetite For Destruction" Demos
-Most of "Lies"
-3/4 of "Use Your Illusion" Demos

are you out of your mind? Where are Huge/Tobias writing credits prior to Chinese outside of Back Off Bitch? Come on....I'll give Tobias credit for Chinese. Prostitute, Catcher, and TWAT just happen to be my favorite songs on the record. But, to compare him to Slash is insane.

gnfnraxl

 Rep: 43 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

gnfnraxl wrote:

Izzy and Slash.

AtariLegend

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

AtariLegend wrote:

^^^ Ha Ha Ha Ha

^^ They were playing them live and recording them...

mickronson

 Rep: 118 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

mickronson wrote:

so..., Tobias is responsible for that anti climax known as Prostitute.. He should be ashamed of himself.

Will

 Rep: 227 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

Will wrote:

and yet, Paul currently leads the poll:

Paul Tobias    
    100% - 2 votes
Slash    
    0% - 0 votes

strat0

 Rep: 13 

Re: Tobias vs. Slash

strat0 wrote:

Paul. As awesome as Slash is, Pual's stuff IMO is better.