Board footer

James

 Rep: 664 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

James wrote:

We do this every year there's leaks, so why change course now?

Didn't include Silkworms, Oh My God, and Catcher in the Rye for obvious reasons.

Definitely Prostitute. Possibly the worst song I've heard this decade.

bigbri

 Rep: 341 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

bigbri wrote:

So, after I voted it was 50-50. Guess I know what you voted for, James! LOL!

monkeychow

 Rep: 661 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

monkeychow wrote:

I'm not into Riyadh, the vocal melodies are less interesting than in the rest of the songs, and the structure sounds like it needs some bridges or something, to me the changes between the verses and chorus don't work.

Von

 Rep: 77 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

Von wrote:

This was tough. Ultimately I went with IRS. Rhiad just has too much to offer. I blatantly disagree on Prostitute, but James and I tend to agree on many other, more important matters.

BrokenGlassNCigs

 Rep: 25 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

BrokenGlassNCigs wrote:

Better, unfortunately.

ereeper

 Rep: 14 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

ereeper wrote:

This is going to be tough.  I went with IRS this time, but I really like all the songs listed.

war

 Rep: 108 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

war wrote:

it's funny how it's not uncommon for journalists and casual listeners, whom have heard the leaks, to connect with irs

yet

a lot of us seem to dislike it.

i have to pick riyadh

it's great at parts but at others i find myself waiting for the next part of the song

faldor

 Rep: 281 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

faldor wrote:

Yeah this is a tough vote as I don't dislike any of the songs.  I chose Madagascar since it's been around longer than the new leaks and it's my least favorite of the original leaks.

Bono

 Rep: 386 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

Bono wrote:

IRS is a total turd of a song. Vocally, musically, lyrically the song sucks ass big time. One of the worst moments in Gn'R history.

alexh0618

 Rep: 14 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 1

alexh0618 wrote:

It came down to IRS and If the World, but since ITW doesn't have that scream and BH solo, it has to go....