Board footer

PaSnow

 Rep: 205 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

PaSnow wrote:

I love the ideas behind Maddy and the direct, simple, heartfelt lyrics. I would eliminate the MLK quotes, but keep the movie stuff. However, the studio version has a horrible vocal (especially the 16 Axl's at the end) and very pitchy, whiny guitars in spots.

Great post. Maddy has a ton of potential, and can certainly be epic, but needs some work done on it. Otherwise it's a poor man's 'Coma'. And Coma isn't even all that.

NY Giants82

 Rep: 26 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

NY Giants82 wrote:

Madagascar

Roxxie

 Rep: 11 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Roxxie wrote:

I voted Madagascar, its one of my least favorite leaks. It's just so bloated and over the top, especially with the quotes but also all the various parts and instruments seem to get in the way.  The melody is alright, but a stripped-down version sure would be a lot better.

mickronson

 Rep: 118 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

mickronson wrote:

Maddy, always will be till its gone. Its lacking whats needed and bloated with whats not.

Scabbie

 Rep: 33 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Scabbie wrote:

Madagascar

rose22

 Rep: 12 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

rose22 wrote:

voted for madagascar. my vote was based on the production of the remaining songs. although i like maddy better than cd, cd is far superior than maddy according to these leaks.

Gunslinger

 Rep: 88 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Gunslinger wrote:

Madagascar...it's definitely bloated.

Saikin

 Rep: 109 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Saikin wrote:

TWAT

Randall Flagg

 Rep: 139 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Randall Flagg wrote:

are we gonna continue this?

James

 Rep: 664 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

James wrote:

Of course. Put this on hold during the Shackler craze.

I'll start the new one now.